Sports

Mets Criticized After Signing Former Yankees Reliever Luke Weaver

2025-12-18 21:38
903 views
Mets Criticized After Signing Former Yankees Reliever Luke Weaver

The New York Mets have made the surprising choice to sign multiple New York Yankees relievers this offseason.

Shaun McAvoyBy Shaun McAvoy

Contributing Sports Writer

ShareNewsweek is a Trust Project member

The New York Mets have been active this offseason in free agency, but an odd pattern has formed around some of their recent acquisitions.

The Mets have surprisingly signed multiple relievers from the New York Yankees. As they were losing Edwin Díaz to the Los Angeles Dodgers in free agency, it made sense that the Mets would target closer Devin Williams. Now, New York has also reportedly poached Luke Weaver, according to MLB.com's Anthony DiComo.

It's not unheard of for the Mets or Yankees to poach free agents from each other, but it is unusual that, including Clay Holmes, the Mets have now signed three former Yankees relievers over the last two years. Yankees commentator Michael Kay criticized the Mets' recent moves, finding their choice to acquire multiple New York relievers interesting.

...

“Even Mets fans would have to admit it’s an odd look, man,” Kay said in a video posted to YouTube by ESPN New York. “You’re putting teams together with guys that the Yankees didn’t want anymore, except for Soto. The Yankees didn’t want Clay Holmes back, they didn’t want Devin Williams back.

“Luke Weaver lost a closer role last year and didn’t pitch well. He did not pitch nearly as well as he did the year before. So maybe the Yankees in their internal discussions said to themselves, ‘We got everything that we could get out of Luke Weaver.’”

The Yankees bullpen was not one of their strong areas this season. Williams' ERA dropped from 1.25 in 2024 to 4.79 this season, while Weaver heavily struggled, especially in the postseason. The Yankees have not made any big splashes in free agency yet this offseason, but remain in the mix for players like Bo Bichette, Kyle Tucker and Cody Bellinger.

More MLB: Yankees Sign 6-Foot-4 Hurler With Nasty Sweeper: Report

Request Reprint & LicensingSubmit CorrectionView Editorial & AI GuidelinesGoogle Preferred Source BannerAdd Newsweek as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.

Recommended For You

Yankees Projected To Acquire $15M Ace In Blockbuster Trade With BrewersMLBYankees Projected To Acquire $15M Ace In Blockbuster Trade With Brewers2 min readBo Bichette Predicted To Sign Massive Contract With AL Club After Big YearMLBBo Bichette Predicted To Sign Massive Contract With AL Club After Big Year2 min readDodgers Predicted To Sign $427 Million Superstar Despite Potential IssueMLBDodgers Predicted To Sign $427 Million Superstar Despite Potential Issue2 min readRed Sox Projected To Retain $182 Million Superstar After Winter MeetingsMLBRed Sox Projected To Retain $182 Million Superstar After Winter Meetings2 min readCardinals Predicted To Cut Ties With Fan Favorite In Trade With MarinersMLBCardinals Predicted To Cut Ties With Fan Favorite In Trade With Mariners2 min readMunetaka Murakami To White Sox? Insider Thinks It’s PossibleMLBMunetaka Murakami To White Sox? Insider Thinks It’s Possible2 min read

Related Podcasts

Top Stories

Epstein Photos: Woman With ‘Lolita’ Quotes Written On Her Body Seen in New Images, As Files Deadline Approaches — RecapNewsEpstein Photos: Woman With ‘Lolita’ Quotes Written On Her Body Seen in New Images, As Files Deadline Approaches — Recap2 min readBrown Mass Shooting Update: Person of Interest Identified — ReportU.S.Brown Mass Shooting Update: Person of Interest Identified — Report4 min readUncommon Knowledge: The Quiet Promise That Could Define Trump’s 2026For MembersNewsUncommon Knowledge: The Quiet Promise That Could Define Trump’s 20264 min readPam Bondi Issued Impeachment Ultimatum Ahead of Epstein Files DeadlineNewsPam Bondi Issued Impeachment Ultimatum Ahead of Epstein Files Deadline5 min readDonald Trump’s Patriot Games Spark Hunger Games ComparisonNewsDonald Trump’s Patriot Games Spark Hunger Games Comparison4 min readGreg Biffle, Family Dead After North Carolina Plane CrashNewsGreg Biffle, Family Dead After North Carolina Plane Crash2 min read

Trending

Flags Ordered To Fly at Half-Staff Across 6 US States Today FlagFlags Ordered To Fly at Half-Staff Across 6 US States Today5 min readFlorida Map Shows Cities That Could Go Underwater if Sea Levels RiseFloridaFlorida Map Shows Cities That Could Go Underwater if Sea Levels Rise5 min readThe White House Makes Glaring Typo on X Post About Joe BidenWhite HouseThe White House Makes Glaring Typo on X Post About Joe Biden4 min readWatch the Exact Moment Dog Realizes He’s Never Going Back to the ShelterDogsWatch the Exact Moment Dog Realizes He’s Never Going Back to the Shelter4 min readGreen Card Update Reveals Major Gains for Applicants—Full List of ChangesGreen CardGreen Card Update Reveals Major Gains for Applicants—Full List of Changes6 min read

Opinion

The World Failed Holocaust Survivors at Bondi Beach | OpinionOpinionThe World Failed Holocaust Survivors at Bondi Beach | Opinion5 min readMake-A-Wish Co-Founder: Healing Communities for 45 Years, One Wish at a Time | OpinionOpinionMake-A-Wish Co-Founder: Healing Communities for 45 Years, One Wish at a Time | Opinion5 min readConventional Wisdom: The Susie Wiles Tell-All EditionFor MembersOpinionConventional Wisdom: The Susie Wiles Tell-All Edition4 min readMore ‘Gun Control’ Is Not the Answer | OpinionOpinionMore ‘Gun Control’ Is Not the Answer | Opinion6 min readThe Bondi Beach Terror Attack Must Strengthen, Not Shatter, Our Bridges | OpinionOpinionThe Bondi Beach Terror Attack Must Strengthen, Not Shatter, Our Bridges | Opinion5 min read